04 | Consumer protection
How are penalties calculated in consumer investigations?
04 | Consumer protection
How are penalties calculated in consumer investigations?
The power to fine
Since April 2025, the Competition and Markets Authority (CMA) has been able to decide for itself that a business has broken consumer protection law and fine it directly, without needing to go through the courts. Under the Digital Markets, Competition and Consumers Act (DMCCA), the CMA can impose a fine of up to £300,000, or 10% of the business's global turnover, whichever is higher (s.182(6) DMCCA).
The CMA is required to publish, and follow, a policy setting out how it decides whether to fine a business and how it works out the amount. That policy sits in Chapter 7 of its Direct Consumer Enforcement Guidance (CMA200), with accompanying procedural rules in CMA201.
The five step test
CMA200 sets out a five-step method for calculating a penalty once the CMA has decided one is justified.
- Step 1 – Starting point. The CMA generally sets a starting figure based on a percentage of the business's relevant UK turnover (up to 30%). The percentage depends on two things: how much harm the conduct caused consumers (ranked from Category 1, most serious, to Category 4, least serious) and how culpable the business was (high, medium or low). Combining these gives a "starting point code" (A to D) which maps onto a percentage range.
- Step 2 – Deterrence. The CMA checks whether the Step 1 figure is large enough to deter the business, and others, from repeating the infringing behaviour. If a business's UK turnover is only a small slice of its global business, or the penalty is smaller than what it likely gained from the conduct, the CMA can increase the figure at this stage.
- Step 3 – Aggravating and mitigating factors. The penalty may be increased for reasons such as the business ignoring a prior warning or trying to hide infringing conduct from the CMA, or decreased for reasons such as the business cooperating well with the investigation or fixing infringing behaviours before being required to by the CMA.
- Step 4 – Proportionality and statutory cap. The CMA assesses whether the overall figure feels proportionate in the circumstances, before ensuring that it doesn't exceed the statutory cap of £300,000 or 10% of worldwide turnover.
- Step 5 – Settlement discount. If the business settles (admits the breach, agrees to a streamlined process and agrees not to appeal), the CMA can apply a maximum penalty discount of up to 40% or 25% (tied to whether the party agrees to settlement discussion terms prior to or after issuance of a Preliminary Investigation Notice by the CMA).
The approach so far
The CMA has now applied this test in six cases: AA/BSM (April 2026), Marks Electrical (June 2026), StubHub (June 2026), Wayfair (October 2026), Appliances Direct (October 2026) and Gold's Gym (October 2026). The AA/BSM, Marks Electrical and Gold's Gym cases give us a fuller picture of the CMA's reasoning, since Final Infringement Notices have been published. The remainder are expected to follow in due course.
In both the AA/BSM and Marks Electrical cases, the CMA categorised the harm as "moderate" (Category 3) and the culpability as "high", landing on starting point code B (a range of 15% to 22.5% of UK turnover).
- AA/BSM. The CMA used AA Limited's group turnover of £1.45 billion as the base and set the starting point at the bottom of the range, 15%, giving a Step 1 figure of £217.5 million. A 5% reduction was applied at Step 3 for cooperation, bringing it to roughly £206.6 million. At Step 4, the CMA decided this figure was disproportionate, largely because the AA is a large, diversified business and only a small slice of that £1.45 billion turnover related to the driving lessons affected by the infringement. It therefore reduced the figure substantially to £7 million (a reduction of about 97% on the Step 1 figure) before application of the settlement discount.
- Marks Electrical. Here the CMA used the company's UK turnover of £117.2 million and set the starting point in the middle of the range, 18%, giving £21.1 million. No aggravating or mitigating factors applied at Step 3. At Step 4, the CMA again found the figure disproportionate, noting that the revenue from the pre-selected add-on services made up only 0.74% of the company's overall turnover, and cut the penalty to £1.2 million (a reduction of about 94% on the Step 1 figure) before application of the settlement discount.
In the Gold’s Gym case, the CMA categorised the harm in the lowest category (Category 4) on the basis that the 726 effected customers had paid only c.£9,220 in joining fees. It nonetheless found culpability to be “high”, as its guidance on drip pricing had been published before the infringing conduct began and the gym had not acted on two warning letters sent by the CMA. It therefore landed on starting point code C (a range of 7.5% to 15% of UK turnover).
- Gold’s Gym. The CMA used the gym’s parent company’s turnover of £7.7 million as the base and set the starting point at the lower end of the range, 7.5%, giving a Step 1 figure of £576,640. No aggravating or mitigating factors applied at Step 3. At Step 4, the CMA once again found the figure disproportionate, as it was far higher than any likely gains from the infringements and only a small proportion of the company’s turnover was derived from online memberships. It therefore reduced the penalty to £75,000 (a reduction of about 87% on the Step 1 figure) before application of the settlement discount.
The cases in summary
The fine and consumer redress are separate tools within the CMA's arsenal of enforcement powers under the DMCCA. The penalty fine is paid to the CMA for the infringing act and to deter repeat behaviour in the future. The redress is money paid back to affected consumers to compensate for harms suffered because of infringing actions. Both cases involved both, but the figures are calculated on a separate basis under CMA200.
What does this tell us about the CMA's approach?
The proportionality step (Step 4) appears to be where the CMA is doing most of the actual work of arriving at a "sensible" penalty figure, particularly by looking at how much of the business's overall turnover was tied to the infringing conduct. A large company with a small problem in one corner of its business isn't (so far) being treated the same as a company whose whole business model is built on the infringing practice.
Second, settling early and engaging constructively is paying off, all three businesses got the full 40% discount available.
Third, the CMA has said clearly that these first-year penalties are likely to be on the lower side precisely because it can only fine conduct from April 2025 onwards, meaning the "duration" element of the harm assessment is necessarily short. The suggestion is that future penalties, for longer-running infringements, will be higher.
See the "Consumer investigations at a glance" section for a summary of the CMA's investigations to date, including the penalties imposed.