04 | Consumer protection

What's new?

Fake reviews

04 | Consumer protection

What's new?

Fake reviews

The Digital Markets, Competition and Consumers Act (DMCCA) also adds (at paragraph 13 of Schedule 20) a set of new banned practices relating to consumer reviews. These provisions were the subject of an initial grace period in relation to enforcement (until July 2025), but the Competition and Markets Authority (CMA) is now enforcing the prohibitions fully and currently has a number of open cases relating to fake review practices (see the "Consumer investigations at a glance section").

Key definitions

  1. Consumer review: this is defined as "a review of a product, a trader or any other matter relevant to a transactional decision" and therefore, in line with many of the other definitions introduced by the DMCCA, its reach is broad. For example, a comment posted under a product listing on a website, a verbal opinion expressed in a video on a social media platform, and a star rating appearing next to a restaurant’s name in search engine results or a thumbs-up next to a "helpful" review would all fall within the definition of a consumer review under the DMCCA.
  2. Consumer review information: this means information derived from or influenced by consumer reviews. Although not specifically set out in the definition itself, the CMA Guidance on Fake Reviews notes that such information may be used to indicate the quality, value, performance or reputation of products or traders, or to allow consumers to compare options.
  3. Fake consumer review: this is "a consumer review that purports to be, but is not, based on a person’s genuine experience". It can be a positive or negative review and whether or not the consumer paid for the item, service or experience being reviewed does not bear any relevance.
  4. Concealed incentivised reviews: these are consumer reviews where: (i) the reviewer has been commissioned to submit or write the review, and (ii) that fact has not been made apparent (whether through the contents of the review or otherwise). The CMA will interpret "commissioned" more widely than monetary benefit – its Guidance on Fake Reviews confirms it encompasses incentivising in the broadest sense such as receiving money, discounts or vouchers, leases or loans on more favourable terms, "freebie" products and stays as well as event invitations (among others).

The banned practices relating to consumer reviews can be categorised under the following headlines. We also set out below some examples and crucial dos and don'ts to be aware of regarding each category of the banned practice.

Fake reviews – dos and don’ts

Submitting, or commissioning another to submit or write a fake consumer review

Examples include:

  • Submitting a positive review about a product when the actual experience was negative.
  • Stating in a review that a product was great but the reviewer had not actually used the product.
  • Purchasing AI-generated reviews which imitate genuine reviews.

To avoid falling foul of the ban on submitting or commissioning fake reviews:

ü
Make sure reviews about the effects of a product are not actually the result of using another product.
û
Do not offer pre-filled text when inviting a customer to leave a review of a product, unless the options cover the full range of consumer experiences and there is an option for consumers to override the pre-filled text to provide their own comments.

Submitting, or commissioning another, to submit or write a consumer review that conceals the fact that it has been incentivised

Examples include:

  • Posting a review which does not reveal that the reviewer received the product for free as part of a commercial relationship with the trader.
  • Offering a product at a discount to an existing customer in exchange for a glowing review of a product bought previously by the customer.
  • Offering a deal which sees customers reimbursed for buying a product once they have submitted a five-star review.
  • Giving financial incentives to customers to change their negative reviews into positive ones.

To make sure that incentivised reviews are not concealed:

ü
Ensure reviews which are incentivised in any way have been clearly labelled as such in a manner way that is clear to viewers (for example, include text to explain that the review has been collected as part of a promotion or other incentivisation scheme). Consider whether this process could be automated to avoid rogue reviews falling through the net.

Publishing consumer reviews, or consumer review information, in a misleading way

Examples include:

  • Stopping genuine negative reviews from being published alongside other reviews.
  • Publishing an aggregate five-star review for a product without accounting for those reviews which have been removed because they may be fake.
  • Publishing outdated genuine reviews about a product when the specifications of that product have materially changed.
  • Counting incentivised reviews, which are essentially advertising, towards an aggregate rating.

To prevent consumer reviews or consumer review information from being published in a misleading way:

û
Avoid supressing genuine reviews or cherry-picking on the positive ones.
û
Ensure that material information about how reviews have been written is not omitted eg, whether reviews have been incentivised in any way.

Publishing consumer reviews, or consumer review information, without taking such reasonable and proportionate steps as are necessary for the purposes of: (a) preventing the publication of fake or concealed reviews or consumer review information that is false or misleading, and (b) removing any such reviews or information from publication

Examples include:

  • Knowing that there are fake reviews on your website and not removing them.
  • Not having a policy covering the prevention, monitoring and removal of fake reviews.

To comply with this positive obligation to prevent and remove banned reviews/information:

ü
Ensure there is a policy in place which covers the prevention and removal of banned, fake or misleading reviews (including, for example, ensuring that only accounts that have made a verified purchase of particular product or service are able to leave a review for that product/service).
ü
Regularly assess the effectiveness of the steps taken to identify and remove fake reviews.
ü
Have systems in place (including automated software) to detect fake reviews and/or allow other users to report potentially suspicious reviews.
ü
Consider appropriate sanctions for posting fake reviews eg banning offending accounts.
ü
Remember, the expectation may be higher for a larger business with more resource, but having insufficient resource won't be a defence for a small business.
û
Do not try to persuade a consumer to submit a complaint instead of leaving a review that will be published.
û
Do not "pass the buck" by obtaining mediocre assurances from third parties when contracting to publish their reviews as the risk arising from fake reviews lies with the publisher.

Offering services to traders for doing or facilitating any of the above practices

Examples include:

  • Offering account set-up services which minimise the risk of fake reviews being detected.
  • Running a website while knowingly allowing traders to use the site to sell fake review services.

Article last updated: October 2026

Return to top