04 | Consumer protection
What if I get it wrong?
Court-based enforcement
04 | Consumer protection
What if I get it wrong?
Court-based enforcement
Since consumer protection provisions under the Digital Markets, Competition and Consumers Act (DMCCA) came into force, it is clear that the focus of the Competition and Markets Authority (CMA) has been on putting its new direct enforcement powers to the test (see the next section of the DMCCA Guide below on these powers). However, the CMA still has the option to pursue action through the courts where: (i) the legislation alleged to have been breached is not within scope of the CMA's direct enforcement powers, (ii) the CMA considers that the practice should be prohibited or prevented urgently and therefore requires an interim enforcement order, or (ii) it is in the public interest to pursue a criminal prosecution.
Activity pre-6 April 2025
The civil court-based enforcement regime under Part 8 of the Enterprise Act 2002 (the Previous Regime) remains the relevant enforcement regime for any infringing conduct occurring prior to 6 April 2025 (ie, the date on which the consumer protection provisions under Part 3 of the DMCCA came into force).
Activity post-6 April 2025
For any infringing conduct occurring after 6 April 2025 or continuing conduct ie, infringing conduct occurring prior to 6 April 2025 but continuing after this date, notwithstanding the CMA's new direct enforcement powers, the CMA can still elect to pursue enforcement action through a revamped civil court-based enforcement regime under the DMCCA. In effect, the CMA now has a dual civil enforcement system at its disposal to tackle breaches of consumer law.
Although broadly, the civil court-based enforcement regime under the DMCCA mirrors the Previous Regime, it introduces some striking changes to enhance the court's enforcement powers, which under the Previous Regime lacked teeth, not least because the court's ability to impose financial penalties was limited.
Under the new court-based enforcement regime, where the CMA (and other enforcers under the DMCCA such as Trading Standards and the Financial Conduct Authority) consider that a business has engaged in, is engaging in, or is likely to engage in a "relevant infringement" (or is an accessory to the infringing practice), it can apply to the court for an enforcement order or an interim enforcement order. Akin to the Previous Regime, a "relevant infringement" is a commercial practice which harms the collective interests of consumers and breaches any of the consumer protection legislation detailed in Schedule 15 of the DMCCA.
Prior to making such an application to the court, the CMA is required to engage in consultation with the party being investigated to seek to prevent or end the infringement or its repetition, and to inform that party that any application for an enforcement order may also include an application for a monetary penalty. This is one of the key changes that the DMCCA brings to the civil court-based enforcement regime – if the court makes a finding of a relevant infringement, it may make an enforcement order requiring the infringing practice to stop or accept undertakings to that effect (in line with the Previous Regime), but it also has the power to impose monetary penalties of up to £300,000 or 10% of total turnover. Further, if a party fails to comply with any undertakings given to the court, enforcement order or online interface order, the CMA can make an additional application to the court, and if the court considers the failure to be "without reasonable excuse" it may impose a further monetary penalty of either: (i) a fixed amount of £150,000 or 5% of turnover, if higher, (ii) a daily rate of £15,000 or 5% of daily turnover, if higher, or (iii) a combination of both.
The future of the CMA's court-based enforcement
The Competition and Markets Authority (CMA)'s direct enforcement cases are evolving at pace. As noted in the next article, the CMA has opened 16 investigations since the regime launched and already resolved 3. In contrast, the CMA's court proceedings against mattress retailer, Emma Sleep in relation to its use of reference pricing have been ongoing since October 2024, with judgment being handed down recently on 30 July 2026. The efficiency with which the CMA can initiate and resolve direct enforcement cases and its enforcement activity is indicating a preference for direct enforcement over court based recourse.
In effect, the CMA now has a dual civil enforcement system at its disposal to tackle breaches of consumer law.