04 | Consumer protection

What if I get it wrong?

The CMA's direct enforcement powers

04 | Consumer protection

What if I get it wrong?

The CMA's direct enforcement powers

The direct enforcement regime is the aspect of the Digital Markets, Competition and Consumers Act (DMCCA) that has everybody talking, as it gives Chapter 1 of Part 4 of the DMCCA (ie, the unfair commercial practice (UCP) provisions) substantial bite.

Prior to the DMCCA, only a court could determine whether a commercial practice had been unfair within the meaning of the Consumer Protection from Unfair Trading Regulations 2008 (CPRs). However, under the DMCCA, the Competition and Markets Authority (CMA) can directly enforce UK consumer protection law. It can make its own determinations about whether a commercial practice is unfair within the meaning of the UCP provisions, and issue substantial penalties without having to go through the courts, including fines and requiring businesses to compensate customers. The result is that it is now much easier for the CMA to take action against businesses it considers to be engaging in unfair commercial practices.

{"chartTitle":"","chartSubtitle":"","series":[{"id":"8dd5bf2b-ce44-4125-9d4c-2e0e21b44a83","data":[16.5],"name":"Fines","color":"rgba(230, 0, 126, 1)"}],"xAxis":{"title":"","categories":["5"]},"yAxis":{"title":""}}

total of imposed fines

Over

150

advisory and warning letters issued

£36m

refunded to consumers

The CMA's direct enforcement powers in action – the story so far

As predicted, the CMA has flexed its new direct enforcement powers – since the direct enforcement regime commenced on 6 April 2026, it has opened investigations into tens of businesses, issued over 150 advisory and warning letters and imposed fines of nearly c. £16.5m. See the "Consumer investigations at a glance" section of the DMCCA guide for an outline of the investigations opened by the CMA under the direct enforcement regime.

As highlighted in its Annual Plan for 2026-2027, the CMA's focus has been on practices which are widespread and causing significant harm – those are fake reviews, hidden or dripped fees, misleading online choice architecture (eg misleading time limited offers and discounts), objectively false consumer information and clearly unfair/imbalanced contract terms (including unfair exit charges).

While there has been an uptake in low-level enforcement activity, we've also seen the CMA reward early settlement with substantial discounts to fines. Of the investigations opened so far, a number resulted in a 40% fine reduction for early settlement. The figures speak for themselves – serious consideration should be given to early settlement where appropriate.

The CMA has sent a clear warning: 18 months on from the commencement of the DMCCA's consumer protection provisions, it expects businesses to understand of the rules and what's expected of them. It will be building out its enforcement practice and is looking to create a deterrent effect for businesses.

As set out in the CMA's Annual Plan for 2026-2027, price transparency (including drip pricing and hidden mandatory fees), fake reviews and unfair contract terms (particularly cancellation and exit charges) will be the areas of focus. However, with the new rules on subscription contracts now set to come in January 2027 and the publication of the CMA's guidance on complying with consumer law when using AI agents in March 2026, the CMA has indicated that businesses should also prioritise compliance in those areas. That said, the CMA has made clear that it's willing to investigate conduct outside of its priority areas if issues become apparent (as demonstrated by its current investigations into Adobe, Euro Car Parks, Ryanair and Microsoft).

The CMA's direct enforcement process

Pre-launch phase:

The CMA will undertake preliminary research and information gathering tasks to decide whether to pursue a case under its direct enforcement powers. This may involve requesting information from public or third parties on a voluntary or compulsory basis, with regards to the latter, via the issuing of an information notice to compel specific information to be provided. If the CMA has reasonable grounds to suspect that a party has engaged, is engaging, is likely to engage in, or is an accessory to an infringing practice, it will open its investigation and publish a notice summarising the matter and the party(s) under investigation.

Investigating phase:

In assessing whether consumer law has been breached, the CMA may exercise its enhanced information gathering powers which, for example, allow it to enter premises and access electronic devices and documents, and/or issue information notices to compel the party under investigation, or any other relevant third parties such as customers, to provide specific information (eg customer or complaint details). Non-compliance with an information notice can result in a monetary penalty. If, following its investigations, the CMA has reasonable grounds to believe that a party has engaged, is engaging, is likely to engage in, or is an accessory to an infringing practice, it will issue a Provisional Infringement Notice (PIN).

Final decision phase:

Upon receiving a PIN, with the exclusion of certain categories of documents, a party can inspect the CMA’s file of documents regarding matters noted in the PIN and make representations in its defence in writing, at a hearing, or both. The CMA will consider the representations to determine either: (i) that a party has engaged is engaging, is likely to engage in, or is an accessory to an infringing practice and issue a Final Information Notice (FIN) detailing its findings and any penalties or directions to be imposed, or (ii) that the case be closed if it’s satisfied that the threshold for issuing a FIN has not been met. Note that prior to the issuing of a FIN, a party may provide undertakings without requiring any admission of infringement or payment of a penalty to resolve the case.

Post-decision phase:

A party may appeal the decision to impose or the amount of a monetary penalty or direction given under a FIN within 60 days of receiving it. The grounds for appeal are: (i) the decision was based on an error of fact, (ii) the decision was wrong in law, (iii) the amount of the penalty or nature of the directions is unreasonable, or (iv) the decision was unreasonable or wrong for any other reason. Whilst any appeal is ongoing, although non-payment related requirements of the FIN will continue to apply, if the appeal relates to payment requirements under the FIN, payments will be deferred until the appeal has been dealt with.

What will the CMA's enforcement activity look like going forwards?

The CMA has sent a clear warning: over a year on from the commencement of the DMCCA's consumer protection provisions, it expects businesses to understand the rules and what's expected of them. It will be building out its enforcement practice and is looking to create a deterrent effect for businesses.

As set out in the CMA's Annual Plan for 2026-2027, price transparency (including hidden mandatory fees), fake reviews and unfair contract terms (particularly cancellation and exit charges) will be the areas of focus. However, with the new rules on subscription contracts now set to come in January 2027 and the publication of the CMA's guidance on complying with consumer law when using AI agents in March 2026, the CMA has indicated that businesses should also prioritise compliance in those areas.

Article last updated: October 2026

Return to top